Quote: Aaron @ August 20, 2007, 11:49 PM

Interestingly, I don't really recall much use of "naughty words". Certainly no more than any other show.

View original

No, that's true. Those that have heard the Radio 1 adverts or seen the BBC2 spots must come away expecting the world's rudest comedy though. The whole premise of the adverts is "it's too rude for us to show here so you'll have to watch it".

Quote: Aaron @ August 20, 2007, 11:49 PM

And Mark, I think you may be the exact target audience. Certainly age-wise, if not sophistication.

View original

Really? I got the feeling they were trying to target the 16 - 18 year old sector with this.

Maybe I am because I ought to say I don't think Grownups is that bad. It's a 'comedy by-the-numbers' sitcom which is fast paced enough that one or two of the jokes hit. (Although I ought to point out I'm not a fan of it either - it's just I don't want to spit when I hear it's name... like I do with a certain other sitcom I mentioned not long ago).
 

---

Mark
BSG Editor
 

Coming of Age has been given a full series, I'm sick of the "Yoof" being catered to all the time especially when they put great shows like Arrested Development on at ridiculous times.


PS, if you want lots of "naughty" words and a damn good show watch Deadwood.
 

Coming of Age. I must say, I'm wondering if that one was so bad it was good.


Generally ditto Mark on Grownups though.
 

---

Aaron
BSG Forums & DVDs Editor
Half man, half Internet, half TV.
(Loyal follower of The Magical Aura of Laura.)

 

Seems to me that the only one not totally biased against Grownups and Two Pints,is Aaron! You seem like a nice guy, a gentle soul, no viciousness in your postings. Must be why you are the BSG Editor and BOSS. Even Mark (BSG Editor), says he hates Two Pints "...sooo much", implying he's watched it '...sooo much'! People should go onto the Two Pints Forums, and read the postings of the army of fans! That's why there have been six series of this sit-com, with a seventh being recorded this Autumn! Could hardly believe the nasty out-pourings of James! Where did all that come from? All over the harmless Grownups, in which we never actually see anything shocking, or hear any F words. He's entitled to his opinion, of course, but he did go on a bit, and then he had to end on a sexist note by commenting on Sheridan's breasts! Just switch off James, and leave lots of us to enjoy this second series. BBC3 asked the writer, Susan Nickson, to make Series 2 more risque, and she certainly has, but I don't consider it offensive, compared to other late-night offerings. Sheridan Smith is a brilliant, versatile actress who never stops working. She has been recording Grownups and the second series of Love Soup, during the Summer, as well as appearing in London's West End, doing eight shows a week as the leading lady in the musical 'Little Shop of Horrors'. This finishes September 8th, then it's Two Pints again. Please give her some credit, and the respect she deserves.
 

 

---

Aaron
BSG Forums & DVDs Editor
Half man, half Internet, half TV.
(Loyal follower of The Magical Aura of Laura.)

 

Quote: Marilyn Richardson @ August 23, 2007, 3:58 AM

People should go onto the Two Pints Forums, and read the postings of the army of fans!

View original

Thanks for logging on and sharing your view Marilyn. Of course everyone is very much entitled to their opinion and you make valid points. I realise Two Pints has a huge following and don't disagree that it makes a lot of people laugh.

I just personally have a grudge against it as it takes up a majority of the repeat slots on BBC3 - a channel which should be repeating a range of things, not just Two Pints.

Anyway, I'm glad you're enjoying Grownups and Two Pints. Do stick around and get involved with the rest of the forum chat!

Quote: Marilyn Richardson @ August 23, 2007, 3:58 AM

Seems to me that the only one not totally biased against Grownups and Two Pints,is Aaron! You seem like a nice guy, a gentle soul, no viciousness in your postings. Must be why you are the BSG Editor and BOSS.

View original

Yes he is a big softie at heart isn't he (as it happens though I'm actually the boss boss - sounds like I'm in the wrong job!)
 

---

Mark
BSG Editor
 

Quote: Mark @ August 23, 2007, 8:42 AM

Yes he is a big softie at heart isn't he

View original

Aye, there's a strawberry chewy centre under this hard shell, if you can crack it.
 

---

Aaron
BSG Forums & DVDs Editor
Half man, half Internet, half TV.
(Loyal follower of The Magical Aura of Laura.)

 

Noticed a preview for ep 6 of this on BBC Three. Isn't the half-cast girl the exact replica of the girl from Two Pints? Even the laugh's the same
 

I feel its a boring silly show.
 

Quote: David H @ August 28, 2007, 7:24 PM

Noticed a preview for ep 6 of this on BBC Three. Isn't the half-cast girl the exact replica of the girl from Two Pints? Even the laugh's the same

View original

Yeah, they're about 80% identical.

Quote: danield1000 @ August 28, 2007, 7:35 PM

I feel its a boring silly show.

View original

It's certainly silly. Some parts, in fact, absolutely fucking stupid. I sit and wonder how the hell it got made at times.

God knows why though, but I can't help liking it. I think there must be something wrong with me.


(Shut up, Leevil. )
 

---

Aaron
BSG Forums & DVDs Editor
Half man, half Internet, half TV.
(Loyal follower of The Magical Aura of Laura.)

 

The writer of 'Two Pints...' and 'Grown Ups' has a very old fashioned style, especially the way she always has her characters adopting posh accents, whenever they try to sound intelligent. It reminds me of the way Tony Hancock use to always do it.
 

Quote: Marilyn Richardson @ August 23, 2007, 3:58 AM

Seems to me that the only one not totally biased against Grownups and Two Pints,is Aaron! You seem like a nice guy, a gentle soul, no viciousness in your postings. Must be why you are the BSG Editor and BOSS. Even Mark (BSG Editor), says he hates Two Pints "...sooo much", implying he's watched it '...sooo much'! People should go onto the Two Pints Forums, and read the postings of the army of fans! That's why there have been six series of this sit-com, with a seventh being recorded this Autumn! Could hardly believe the nasty out-pourings of James! Where did all that come from? All over the harmless Grownups, in which we never actually see anything shocking, or hear any F words. He's entitled to his opinion, of course, but he did go on a bit, and then he had to end on a sexist note by commenting on Sheridan's breasts! Just switch off James, and leave lots of us to enjoy this second series. BBC3 asked the writer, Susan Nickson, to make Series 2 more risque, and she certainly has, but I don't consider it offensive, compared to other late-night offerings. Sheridan Smith is a brilliant, versatile actress who never stops working. She has been recording Grownups and the second series of Love Soup, during the Summer, as well as appearing in London's West End, doing eight shows a week as the leading lady in the musical 'Little Shop of Horrors'. This finishes September 8th, then it's Two Pints again. Please give her some credit, and the respect she deserves.

View original

Yikes. Still, I think I will respond as best I can, being as I was particulary singled out.
(You know, I'm not sure Grownups IS harmless. It could be the epitome of dumbed-down television. And give me swearing, if it's funny. I'm no prude.)

The comments are very protective - almost like the poster's ego is invested in the show in some way.

Quote: Marilyn Richardson @ August 23, 2007, 3:58 AM

Just switch off James, and leave lots of us to enjoy this second series.

View original

I did switch off, but I feel I'm entitled to give the show an initial chance and air my unbelief at what I, and the vast majority of critics, see as its poor quality. I don't feel I need to 'leave people alone', if that is the inference, as I don't consider myself to be impairing others' (other's?!) enjoyment. The fact that I "went on a bit" is a lame criticism. Besides, I pay my licence fee. That makes it worse!

Whilst comedy, as an art form, is a subjective medium, some extremes strike a particular chord. Singing can be considered art. But tone-deaf is tone-deaf. Digression: I directed a musical at university and had a discussion (we were too civilised for an argument, in the heated sense of the word, of course!) about one of the songs sung by one of the singers. On the night of the performance, I was unhappy with the song. My friend loved it, and couldn't see what I was talking about. We played back the DVD of the performance and most of the notes were very, very flat. This was an indisputable fact. My point? Some people are just less discerning than others. I sound arrogant there, I suppose, but we all have our "weak spots" or "indulgences". Maybe art itself is a blending of the imperfect and the perfect to appeal to select audiences. Anyway, I'm spiralling into pretentious crap here.

What I'm saying is, I'm sure a few people did like Grownups. But I don't feel I'm in a position where I have to defend my view. Frankly, Grownups is the musical equivalent of first-round X Factor. There's no art to the programme (or at least the 2-3 episodes I saw). And to use the Louise character again out of Two Pints - she's not Falstaff, for crying out loud! What sheer creative bankruptcy.

Re: Sheridan Smith, again I think the "sexist" barb is a misfired one, intended more to discredit me and add some only tangentially relevant, and still highly contestable, ballast to what is essentially a weak defence of a poor quality programme. My comment was ironic (but nonetheless grounded in fact). And in fact, if anyone cares to "check out" the fansite of this presumably very talented actress (maybe she is - she's good enough, I've no criticism of her - but she's not had brilliant vehicles, from what I've seen), http://www.lightningspider.co.uk/serv01/sheridansmith82/ (top result in Google search for Sheridan smith fansite) one will see exactly what her "fans" perceive her talents to be. Note the links to the left. All relevant to her and her talents? Maybe this is sad, or sexist. In this context, I think it is. Maybe 50% of the population enjoy looking at breasts. This isn't sexist, this is a fact. And bearing this in mind, if we're going to throw such accusations around (which is not advisable) it is the producers/directors/writers of such shows that are fault for blatantly presenting Sheridan as such an object at times - and for giving her such crap vehicles where all bored viewers can do is drool. We're all aware that they're doing this - and I don't think this observation can be considered sexist in itself.

The opinion the majority of posters represent is not "bias", it's "opinion". Which we are all entitled to.
Suggesting that the one poster who has anything positive to say about the show is the "only one not totally biased" is, clearly, biased. Recommending people look at the Two Pints forums to see the praise there is irrelevant on a number of levels.

Anyway, whilst my views may have seemed rather forcefully put, I think Grownups was proportionately bad, and my views were considered and supported. I would like to hear some considered analysis of what exactly was supposed to be funny about the show. "We murder to dissect" and all that, but if anyone liked it it could presumably be done.

I hope that wasn't too long-winded and pompous.
 

---

Things fall apart.

www.newstroupe.co.uk
 

Woah, think the 'longest post of the month award' is in the bag for you James!

I tend to agree with what you say (my dislike of Two Pints is rather well documented). But, as a general note to everyone, I think but we must remember that these comedies, whilst we don't like them, do have a number of fans. They just don't tend to hang out here* which is why Marilyn has probably felt the need to defend the show.

* I won't say why I think the Two Pints and Grownups fans tend to be on other websites and not here - that will definitely get me in trouble!
 

---

Mark
BSG Editor
 

Quote: Mark @ November 20, 2007, 12:05 AM

Woah, think the 'longest post of the month award' is in the bag for you James!

I tend to agree with what you say (my dislike of Two Pints is rather well documented). But, as a general note to everyone, I think but we must remember that these comedies, whilst we don't like them, do have a number of fans. They just don't tend to hang out here* which is why Marilyn has probably felt the need to defend the show.

* I won't say why I think the Two Pints and Grownups fans tend to be on other websites and not here - that will definitely get me in trouble!

View original

I'm sure it'll be the only award I get for some time! I tend to ramble in putting relatively straightforward points across, perhaps. Or: I talk too much.

I've got no problem with people enjoying what they want to enjoy - in fact, I'm pretty liberal in all areas. Whatever knocks you out. Certainly don't like to think of myself as a Comedy Nazi. I'm happy for people to enjoy themselves. Similarly, though, I have the right to hate something. (So long as it's not anything like small children. Or Fawlty Towers.)

Hope I don't sound like I'm (too) censorious of others' likes.
 

---

Things fall apart.

www.newstroupe.co.uk
 

Quote: James Williams @ November 19, 2007, 11:52 PM

But I don't feel I'm in a position where I have to defend my view.

View original

He says, defending his view voraciously.
 

---

Aaron
BSG Forums & DVDs Editor
Half man, half Internet, half TV.
(Loyal follower of The Magical Aura of Laura.)