Login or Register
  or
   
Forgotten Your Login?

CloseClose
The British Sitcom Guide Forums YouGov Surveys - Get Paid for Your Opinions
Page: 1 2 3 4
PrintReply
Author Topic: Green Wing Appreciation Thread
SlagA
Avatar of SlagA
Moderator
Posts: 2267
Location: Wales

Offline

View user's profile 

Watched the whole second series (not seen first yet).

Very good episodic highly-fractured show, so patchy by its own nature, (especially the unrealistic Sue White set within a real context - by far the most disjunct character in nearly every show I've seen) but the emotional payoff at the end of the second series was a BIG letdown.

Having Mac ride off into the sunset, leaving Todd on the platform. Not good. Not even the worst person on earth would really do that. At least an enigmatic phone call or if not a quick visit to the platform to make an excuse. Riding off was a coward's way out for the character and the writers. It felt more like an episode end rather than a series end.

Okay, maybe they already knew there was to be a special but in truth a series should be a self-contained unit that makes sense within its own context. It can't make an appeal to "ah, but there's more." Red Dwarf tried that and it really peed me off. You only cheat the viewer.

People may say that not everything needs a happy end but happy or sad a film / book / series needs an ENDING and that wasn't a true ending, it was simply a jagged interruption to the continuing storyline.

Apart from that, it is by far the best comedy to come out of the UK for a long time.
 
The Slagg Brothers live at:welshwriters.org.uk/slaggbrothers.

Our MySpace. Feel free to add us as friends.

Our YouTube. Subscribe to us and we'll return the compliment.

For ropey vocals and out-of-control guitar try: The Myth Makers
 
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
Mark
Administrator
Posts: 1605
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile 

A good summary SlagA! Bit odd you watched the second series first... you probably should have watched them in order as there are a few 'in jokes' in series two that can only be appreciated after having seen the first.

More generally though, if you enjoyed the second series do check out the first - most people agree it was more tightly scripted and generally the better of the two. Might be a bit odd watching it now though - it'll introduce characters you're already familiar with.
 
Mark
BSG Editor

 
Quote this post
 
SlagA
Avatar of SlagA
Moderator
Posts: 2267
Location: Wales

Offline

View user's profile 

Cheers, we won the second series in a competition, so that was the reason why, but I will hunt down series 1.
 
The Slagg Brothers live at:welshwriters.org.uk/slaggbrothers.

Our MySpace. Feel free to add us as friends.

Our YouTube. Subscribe to us and we'll return the compliment.

For ropey vocals and out-of-control guitar try: The Myth Makers
 
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
David Chapman
Member
Posts: 8220
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile 

And then the Christmas Specials which rounded things off - to some extent!
 
http://www.myspace.com/chavid_productions
 
Quote this post
 
sen XD
Member
Posts: 3
Location: Scotland

Offline

View user's profile 

Hey guys, I have posted several of the soundtracks on youtube. Search for "green wing soundtrack" Thought you would like to know! [:
 
Conviscatio Secundo!
 
Quote this post
 
PrintReply
Page: 1 2 3 4

 

Content copyright © 2006-2008 BSG and respective authors.
Board copyright © 2001-2008 Aaron Brown, v1.0.4 beta.